Style & Wardrobe The Shortlist
The Best Affordable Cashmere Sweaters
By Goldie ·
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. Here's how that works.
“Affordable cashmere” used to be a contradiction. It isn’t anymore. A handful of brands now sell genuine Grade A cashmere for what a decent cotton sweater used to cost, and the only hard part is knowing which ones are worth it.
We compared the most popular options on the four things that actually matter, grade, ply, price, and return policy, and sorted them by budget. If you want the reasoning behind those specs first, the cashmere buying guide breaks them all down.
The picks at a glance
| Tier | Pick | Price | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| For most people | Quince Mongolian Crewneck | ~$50 | Grade A at 15.8 micron, 365-day returns |
| The step-up | Everlane Grade-A Crew | ~$100 | Grade A, more structured knit, frequent sales |
| The story pick | Naadam The Original | $98 | Herder-direct sourcing, fashion-forward colors |
| The splurge | Vince Plush Cashmere Crew | ~$468 | Two-ply boiled yarn, lofted luxury hand |
For most people: Quince Mongolian Cashmere Crewneck
This is the one we recommend to almost everyone. It’s about $50, it’s certified Grade A Mongolian cashmere measuring 15.8 microns, and it ships with a 365-day return window. That combination of a published fiber spec and a year to return it is rare at any price, let alone this one.
It’s not the heaviest or most structured knit in this list. But for softness, value, and low risk, nothing here beats it.
The step-up: Everlane Grade-A Cashmere Crew
Everlane’s crew is also Grade-A Mongolian cashmere, with a slightly more structured, mid-weight knit that holds its shape well. List price is around $100, and it goes on sale often enough that patient shoppers can catch it closer to $75.
Reviewers do flag some surface fuzzing after a couple months, so plan on owning a cashmere comb. If you want a touch more heft than the Quince and you like Everlane’s cuts, this is a solid pick.
The story pick: Naadam The Original
Naadam built its name on a “$75 cashmere sweater,” now $98. The draw here is the supply chain. Naadam sources directly from herders in the Mongolian Gobi, and the colors and shapes lean more fashion-forward than a plain basic. The catch is a 14-day return window with a $12.75 return fee. We compared it head to head with Quince in this breakdown.
The splurge: Vince Plush Cashmere Crew
When you want cashmere that feels like an investment, Vince is the honest splurge. The Plush Cashmere Crew runs around $468 and uses a two-ply yarn that’s boiled for a dense, lofted, almost cloud-like finish. You’re paying for the finishing work and the drape, not a higher fiber grade. If you wear cashmere constantly and want one piece that feels special, it delivers.
Also considered
- Old Navy and other mall brands sell cashmere-blend sweaters, often for very little. They’re fine as a trendy, low-stakes buy, but a blend is not 100% cashmere and won’t feel or last the same. Buy them knowing that.
- Department-store house brands at Nordstrom and Bloomingdale’s are worth a look on sale, but read the label for grade and ply before you commit. Many stay quiet on both.
The bottom line
Spend $50 on the Quince and you’ll be happy. Spend $468 on the Vince and you’ll be happy in a different way. Everything in between is about whether you’re paying for a knit you love or a story you believe in. Both are valid reasons. Just don’t pay luxury prices for a sweater that won’t tell you its grade.